History Rethinking Patriarchy: Gerda Lerner’s Intellectual Legacy In Gender History

Rethinking Patriarchy: Gerda Lerner’s Intellectual Legacy In Gender History

Gerda Lerner was a pioneer of women's history research and a forceful intellectual figure in feminist scholarship.
» Editors Note: #MoodOfTheMonth for March 2025 is Women’s History Month. We invite submissions on this theme throughout the month. If you would like to contribute, kindly refer to our submission guidelines and email your articles to shahinda@feminisminindia.com

Gerda Lerner (1920–2013) was an early historian and feminist scholar whose work transformed women’s history on its very foundation. As an educator, not only did she reclaim the erasure of the stories of women throughout history, but she created women’s history as a new scholarly discipline as well. Her work provided us with a foundation for analysing women’s structural oppression and the formation of patriarchy over time.

Gerda Lerner’s early life and influences

Gerda Lerner was born Gerda Hedwig Kronstein on April 30, 1920, in Vienna, Austria, into an assimilated Jewish family. Her father was a pharmacist named Robert Kronstein, and her mother was an artist named Ilona Kronstein. The struggles that her mother’s failed attempt to have an independent artistic career left on young Gerda had long-lasting effects and shaped her beliefs about women’s roles and barriers they encountered within patriarchal culture.

The political crisis in Europe in the 1930s greatly impacted Lerner’s intellectual and political development. Due to fascism and the German annexation of Austria in 1938, Germany’s Gestapo arrested Lerner and her mother as a way of forcing her father to sell his property. After being detained for a month, she and her mother were released and fled to Liechtenstein. This early experience of political repression and violence at the hands of the state gave her a foundation for the activism she was to later perform in support of social justice as well as for historical study.

Immigration to the United States and early activist

Lerner came to the United States in 1939, where she struggled at first to make a living. She took on a succession of jobs—waitress, office worker, X-ray technician—before becoming settled in her adopted homeland. She wedded Carl Lerner, a film editor with intense leftist political activism, in 1941. The two were socially active in social justice and actively participated in Communist and labour movements. Gerda Lerner was also involved in grassroots activism at this time, struggling for workers’ rights, racial justice, and gender equality.

Source: gerdalerner.com

Her early activism was demonstrated by organising demonstrations, writing political tracts, and working on community projects. She co-authored a screenplay, Black Like Me (1964), with her husband based on the true story of a white journalist who had impersonated a Black man in order to experience racial segregation firsthand. This early introduction to the problem of oppression led to her later academic work in examining the history of women’s struggles.

Academic life and the development of women’s history

Lerner’s formal academic life began later in life. She earned her Bachelor of Arts degree from the New School for Social Research in 1963 and subsequently a Ph.D. in history at Columbia University, which she earned in 1966. Her doctoral dissertation, The Grimké Sisters from South Carolina: Rebels Against Slavery (1967), was a pioneering work in women’s history. Through an examination of the activism of Angelina and Sarah Grimké—two 19th-century white abolitionist sisters who defied the rules—Lerner illuminated the intersections of race, gender, and social reform movements.

Recognising the glaring absence of women’s voices in the historical record, Lerner dedicated herself to establishing women’s history as a field of study. In 1972, she developed the first master’s program in women’s history at Sarah Lawrence College. She went on to establish the first Ph.D. programme in women’s history at the University of Wisconsin–Madison in 1980. These programmes provided a much-needed intellectual foundation for the study of women’s lives, inspiring a new generation of historians to critically examine gender and power relations.

Major works and intellectual contributions

Lerner’s work helped shape women’s history and feminist scholarship in a great way. She argued that women’s marginalisation from history was not absence from participation in historical forces but the way history was composed and structured. Some of her most significant writings are as follows:

The Creation of Patriarchy (1986)

In The Creation of Patriarchy, Lerner examined the development of male dominance from ancient Mesopotamia through classical antiquity. She refuted that patriarchy was a natural or biological reality but a social creation over centuries. She traced the origins of institutionalised male supremacy and defied assumptions that gender inequality was inherent. Her book was central in demonstrating how history could be used as a tool for affirming systemic oppression.

The Creation of Feminist Consciousness (1993)

This book served as a companion to The Creation of Patriarchy, exploring how women throughout history developed a collective consciousness of their oppression and resistance. Lerner examined the intellectual traditions of women from the Middle Ages to the 19th century, showing how they constructed feminist thought despite being excluded from formal education and public discourse. This work was critical in demonstrating that feminist movements were not modern phenomena but had deep historical roots.

Why History Matters: Life and Thought (1997)

With this collection of essays, Lerner argued on behalf of the importance of historical inquiry in relation to social and political change. She felt that historical study was essential to fight oppression and build a more just society. From lived experience as well as scholarly analysis, she lit up the application of history to feminist movement and consciousness.

Gerda Lerner’s legacy and impact

Lerner’s influence on women’s history extended far beyond the classroom. She worked to introduce women’s history into the university curriculum so that women’s studies could be an established and accepted field of historical scholarship. Her impact can be seen through the creation of women’s studies programmes throughout the world.

Source: womenneedtoclimbmountains.com

Besides, Lerner’s work spawned generations of feminist historians who could question traditional historical accounts and challenge how gender has built human societies. By providing a historical context for the understanding of patriarchy and women’s resistance, she laid the foundation for critical feminist historiography.

Apart from her academic writing, Lerner’s intellectual legacy and activism inspire contemporary social movements. Her call for the significance of women’s voices in history has profoundly affected feminist theory, gender studies, and historical practice.

Gerda Lerner was a pioneer of women’s history research and a forceful intellectual figure in feminist scholarship. Her life—resisting fascism in Nazi Austria, opening the way for scholarly work on women’s history in the United States—was defined by a ferocious commitment to justice, to education, to historical truth. Through her research, her pedagogy, her activism, she remade the terrain of historical scholarship so that women’s work and struggle could no longer be overlooked. Her work remains central to understanding historical constructions of patriarchy, feminist consciousness, and the power of historical research in building social change. As scholars and activists today grapple with issues of gender, history, and oppression, Lerner’s legacy is more important than ever.


References 

  1. https://www.womenshistory.org/education-resources/biographies/gerda-lerner
  2. https://www.radcliffe.harvard.edu/schlesinger-library/collections/gerda-lerner
  3. https://journals.openedition.org/cliowgh/324

About the author(s)

Faga Jaypal is a final year history student at Sri Venkateswara College, University of Delhi, with a keen interest in intellectual history, gender and sexuality studies, social justice, and cultural studies. Passionate about literature, books, and museums, he combines his love for storytelling with academic research. Aspiring to become a teacher like Mr. Keating, he seeks to explore history through diverse narratives.

Leave a Reply

Related Posts

Skip to content